100% Free

No Scanner Needed

Carly logo

leakrause1

Oil Warning Lights? Check These Signs of Contamination

Oil pressure warning + check engine light, possible oil contamination? Running a 2021 Chevy Cavalier (gas) with 130k on the clock. Oil pressure warning suddenly popped up along with the check engine light. Last mechanic visit wasn't great, so I'm concerned about potential engine damage. Has anyone dealt with similar warning lights? Wondering if this could be oil sludge or just a bad sensor. Should I check the oil color first or take it straight to a different shop? Any tips on spotting a trustworthy mechanic who won't rip me off with unnecessary repairs? Looking for real experiences and advice before I make my next move.

4 comment(s)

siegfriedtiger77

Had a similar issue with my 2018 Chevy Malibu last month. Oil pressure warning combined with CEL usually points to serious oil contamination or oil sludge buildup, definitely not something to ignore. First step: Check your oil level and color. Dark, gritty oil with a burnt smell typically indicates significant sludge buildup. My engine oil looked exactly like that when I checked. The fix required a complete oil system flush, new oil filter, and fresh synthetic oil. The mechanic also found sludge deposits throughout the engine, which was causing the pressure problems. Turned out I'd gone way past recommended maintenance intervals. Word of advice: don't drive it much until checked, oil pressure issues can lead to major engine damage if ignored. Look for a shop that specializes in domestic vehicles and offers diagnostic testing before any repairs. A reputable mechanic will show you the contaminated oil and explain exactly what needs fixing. This isn't a simple sensor issue, oil sludge buildup needs proper attention to prevent permanent engine damage.

leakrause1 (Author)

Yeah, dealing with those oil pressure warnings is nerve-wracking. Had the exact same combo of warning lights in my Cavalier. Turned out my engine oil was badly contaminated and had created some nasty sludge deposits. The oil filter was completely clogged too. The shop did a full system flush, replaced all filters, and added some oil additives to help clean out the remaining gunk. Just curious, what did the repairs end up costing you? And has everything been running smoothly since the fix? My repair bill was pretty hefty, but it beat having to replace the whole engine. Been super strict about oil changes since then, learned that lesson the hard way.

siegfriedtiger77

Got everything sorted since my last post! The oil contamination issue was completely fixed, total bill came to 165 for the service, which included a thorough system flush and fresh oil change. Pretty reasonable considering what could've happened if left unchecked. My Malibu's running like new now, no more warning lights or pressure problems. The oil pressure has stayed steady and the engine's much quieter. The mechanic showed me the old oil they drained out, it was seriously contaminated, way worse than regular dirty oil. Best thing I did was catching it early. An oil leak or complete engine damage would've cost way more than what I paid for the fix. Now I'm religious about following the maintenance intervals, got a reminder set on my phone and everything. Quick tip: if you're worried about your oil pressure, checking the dipstick regularly can catch problems before they get serious. Clean oil should look golden, not black and gritty like mine was.

leakrause1 (Author)

Thanks for sharing your experience. After all those warning lights showed up, I bit the bullet and took my Cavalier to a new mechanic last week. Turns out it was pretty serious, thick black oil sludge everywhere and the oil pressure sensor was barely functioning. The repair took a full day. They did a complete engine flush, replaced the oil pressure sensor, put in new filters, and added some special oil additives to help clean out the remaining deposits. Hit me for €580 total, which stung but honestly could've been way worse if I'd kept driving it. Been running great since then, no more warning lights and the engine's much smoother. The mechanic actually showed me the contaminated oil they drained out, looked like tar! Made me realize how bad I'd let it get. Started keeping a maintenance log now and set reminders for regular oil changes. Never letting it get that bad again. Those warning lights were definitely a wake-up call.

Join the discussion now: